1887

Creating a Three-Parent Child: An Educational Paradigm for the Responsible Conduct of Research

    Authors: Ruth L. Fischbach1,*, Shawna Benston1, John D. Loike1
    VIEW AFFILIATIONS HIDE AFFILIATIONS
    Affiliations: 1: Center for Bioethics, Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons, New York, NY 10032
    AUTHOR AND ARTICLE INFORMATION AUTHOR AND ARTICLE INFORMATION
    • Published 15 December 2014
    • 1 That this House takes note of the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority’s most recent scientific review into the safety and efficacy of mitochondrial replacement techniques which highlights concerns for subsequent generations of children born through maternal spindle transfer and pronuclear transfer; welcomes the recent comments of scientists including Professor Lord Winston that, prior to the introduction of such techniques, more research ought to be undertaken and a full assessment conducted of the potential risk to children born as a result; and calls upon the Government, in light of these public safety concerns, to delay bringing forward regulations on mitochondrial replacement (http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201415/cmhansrd/cm140901/debtext/140901-0003.htm#14090125000001).
    • *Corresponding author. Mailing address: Center for Bioethics, Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons, 630 West 168th Street, Box 161, New York, NY 10032. Fax: 212-342-0541. E-mail: [email protected].
    • ©2014 Author(s). Published by the American Society for Microbiology.
    Source: J. Microbiol. Biol. Educ. December 2014 vol. 15 no. 2 186-190. doi:10.1128/jmbe.v15i2.873
MyBook is a cheap paperback edition of the original book and will be sold at uniform, low price.
  • PDF
    194.25 Kb
  • XML
  • HTML
    40.34 Kb

    Abstract:

    The field of assisted reproduction is renowned for its remarkable advances and constant pushing forward of research boundaries in an effort to offer innovative and effective methods for enhancing fertility. Accompanying these advances, however, are physiological, psychological, and bioethical consequences that must be considered. These concomitant advances and consequences make assisted reproduction an excellent educational paradigm for inculcating responsible conduct in both research and clinical practice. Ultimately, responsible conduct rests on the ethical researcher and clinician. Here, we present the as-yet unapproved, contentious assisted reproductive technology of mitochondrial replacement transfer (MRT) as an ideal educational platform to foster the responsible conduct of research by advancing dialogue among multi-disciplinary scholars, researchers, and students. Using a likely future case, we present the basic science, legal, and ethical considerations, and the pedagogical principles and strategies for using MRT as an effective educational paradigm. Society will benefit when the ethical issues inherent in creating children with three genetic parents as well as germline interference are discussed across multiple academic levels that include researchers, legal experts, bioethicists, and government-appointed commissions. Furthermore, undergraduate and graduate students should be included because they will likely determine the ethical fates of these biotechnologies. While emerging assisted reproduction technologies such as MRT are highly complex and will take years to be readily available for patients in need, now is the time to consider their scientific, legal, ethical, and cultural/religious implications for ensuring the responsible conduct of research.

Key Concept Ranking

Mitochondrial DNA
0.55
Nuclear Chromosome
0.53125
0.55

References & Citations

1. American Medical Association Informed Consent, available at http://www.hg.org/informed-consent-law.html (last visited Nov. 4, 2014).
2. Appelbaum PS, Roth LH, Lidz CW, Benson P, Winslade W 1987 False hopes and best data: consent to research and the therapeutic misconception Hastings Cent Rep 17 20 24 10.2307/3562038 3294743 http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/3562038
3. Baylis F 2013 The ethics of creating children with three genetic parents Reprod BioMedicine Online 26 531 534 532 10.1016/j.rbmo.2013.03.006 http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.rbmo.2013.03.006
4. Belmont Report 1979 The Belmont Report: ethical principles and guidelines for the protection of human subjects of research [Online.] hhs.gov/ohrp/humansubjects/guidance/belmont.html.
5. Benston S 2013 What’s law got to do with it?: Why we should mediate, rather than litigate, cases of wrongful life Cardozo J Conflict Resol 15 243 270
6. Code of Federal Regulations 2014 Title 21, Volume 5, Revised as of April 1, 2014. 21CFR31222 US Government Printing Office Washington, DC
7. Cutas DE 2008 On a Romanian attempt to legislate on medically assisted human reproduction Bioethics 22 56 63
8. Declaration of Helsinki 2013 Ethical Principles for Medical Research Involving Human Subjects WMA Adopted by the 18th WMA General Assembly Helsinki, Finland June 1964 amended by the 64th WMA General Assembly Fortaleza, Brazil October 2013 See Tenant 26.
9. Egea RR, Puchalt NG, Escrivá MM, Varghese AC 2014 OMICS: current and future perspectives in reproductive medicine and technology J Hum Reprod Sci 7 73 92 10.4103/0974-1208.138857 25191020 4150148 http://dx.doi.org/10.4103/0974-1208.138857
10. FDA Briefing Document 2014 Oocyte modification in assisted reproduction for the prevention of transmission of mitochondrial disease or treatment of infertility Cellular, Tissue, and Gene Therapies Advisory Committee, Meeting # 59 February 25–26
11. Gray K 2013 Florida judge approves birth certificate listing three parents NBC News. [Online.] http://usnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2013/02/07/16889720-florida-judge-approves-birth-certificate-listing-three-parents?lite
12. Horng S, Grady C 2003 Misunderstanding in clinical research: distinguishing therapeutic misconception, therapeutic misestimation, and therapeutic optimism IRB: Ethics Hum. Res. 25 11 16 10.2307/3564408 http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/3564408
13. Lawyersandsettlements Sperm donor deemed ‘father’ and must pay child support [Online.] http://www.lawyersandsettlements.com/lawsuit/sperm-donor-deemed-father-must-pay-child-support.html#.VAn9eenSdN (last visited September 5, 2014).
14. Loike JD, Tendler MD 2014 Creating human embryos using reproductive cloning technologies J Halacha Contemp Soc 67 37 60
15. Loike JD, Hirano M, Margalit H 2013 Three-way parenthood: dealing with the logistics of embryos created by three-parent IVF technologies that avoid the transmission of mitochondrial disease Scientist October 1 2013
16. Margalit Y, Levy HO, Loike JD 2014 The new frontier of advanced reproductive technology: reevaluating modern legal parenthood Harvard J. Law Gender 37 107 139
17. Narayan C 2014 Kansas court says sperm donor must pay child support. CNN.com 24 January 2014 [Online.] http://www.cnn.com/2014/01/23/justice/kansas-sperm-donation/ (last visited Sept. 5, 2014).
19. Nuremberg Trials 1949 Trials of War Criminals before the Nuremberg Military Tribunals under Control Council Law No. 10, Vol. 2, p 181–182 US Government Printing Office Washington, DC
20. Papenfuss M 2014 California bill would let birth certificates reflect same-sex parents Reuters. [Online.] http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/08/21/us-usa-california-lgbt-rights-idUSKBN0GL04J20140821
21. Paull DE, et al 2013 Nuclear genome transfer in human oocytes eliminates mitochondrial DNA variants Nature 493 632 637 10.1038/nature11800 http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nature11800
22. Recht SM 1988 M is for money: Baby M and the surrogate motherhood controversy Am U Law Rev 37 1013 1050
23. Reinhardt K, Dowling DK, Morrow EH 2013 Medicine. Mitochondrial replacement, evolution, and the clinic Science 341 1345 1346 10.1126/science.1237146 24052294 http://dx.doi.org/10.1126/science.1237146
24. Russell O, Turnbull D 2014 Mitochondrial DNA disease-molecular insights and potential routes to a cure Exp Cell Res 325 38 43 10.1016/j.yexcr.2014.03.012 24675282 4058519 http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.yexcr.2014.03.012
25. Sanchini V, Reni M, Calori G, Riva E, Reichlin M 2012 Informed consent as an ethical requirement in clinical trials: an old, but still unresolved issue. An observational study to evaluate patients’ informed consent comprehension J. Med. Ethics 40 269 275 10.1136/medethics-2012-101115 http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/medethics-2012-101115
26. Tachibana M, et al 2013 Towards germline gene therapy of inherited mitochondrial diseases Nature 493 627 631 10.1038/nature11647 3561483 http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nature11647
27. Tingley K 2014 The brave new world of three-parent I.V.F. New York Times 27 June 2014 [Online.] http://www.nytimes.com/2014/06/29/magazine/the-brave-new-world-of-three-parent-ivf.html?module=Search&mabReward=relbias%3Ar
28. Wolf DP, Mitalipov S 2014 Mitochondrial replacement therapies can circumvent mtDNA-based disease transmission Cell Metab 20 6 8 10.1016/j.cmet.2014.06.012 24988456 4095871 http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cmet.2014.06.012

Supplemental Material

No supplementary material available for this content.

Loading

Article metrics loading...

/content/journal/jmbe/10.1128/jmbe.v15i2.873
2014-12-15
2019-03-21

Abstract:

The field of assisted reproduction is renowned for its remarkable advances and constant pushing forward of research boundaries in an effort to offer innovative and effective methods for enhancing fertility. Accompanying these advances, however, are physiological, psychological, and bioethical consequences that must be considered. These concomitant advances and consequences make assisted reproduction an excellent educational paradigm for inculcating responsible conduct in both research and clinical practice. Ultimately, responsible conduct rests on the ethical researcher and clinician. Here, we present the as-yet unapproved, contentious assisted reproductive technology of mitochondrial replacement transfer (MRT) as an ideal educational platform to foster the responsible conduct of research by advancing dialogue among multi-disciplinary scholars, researchers, and students. Using a likely future case, we present the basic science, legal, and ethical considerations, and the pedagogical principles and strategies for using MRT as an effective educational paradigm. Society will benefit when the ethical issues inherent in creating children with three genetic parents as well as germline interference are discussed across multiple academic levels that include researchers, legal experts, bioethicists, and government-appointed commissions. Furthermore, undergraduate and graduate students should be included because they will likely determine the ethical fates of these biotechnologies. While emerging assisted reproduction technologies such as MRT are highly complex and will take years to be readily available for patients in need, now is the time to consider their scientific, legal, ethical, and cultural/religious implications for ensuring the responsible conduct of research.

Highlighted Text: Show | Hide
Loading full text...

Full text loading...

/deliver/fulltext/jmbe/15/2/jmbe-15-186.xml.a.html?itemId=/content/journal/jmbe/10.1128/jmbe.v15i2.873&mimeType=html&fmt=ahah

This is a required field
Please enter a valid email address
Please check the format of the address you have entered.
Approval was a Success
Invalid data
An Error Occurred
Approval was partially successful, following selected items could not be processed due to error